Operations

A Subscription Checkout Audit for Telehealth Brands, Line by Line, After This Fall's ROSCA Rulings

Two federal cases now test telehealth subscription checkouts under the Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act. In Florida, a court let the government's claims against Zealthy proceed, finding the complaint adequately alleges that the full cost was not disclosed. In California, Hims has moved to dismiss the FTC's case, with a hearing reported for January 7, 2027. With Louisiana's auto-renewal law starting January 1, here is an audit to run on your own checkout: eight elements, what the law asks, what to check, and the record to keep.

Two cases, one statute

The Restore Online Shoppers' Confidence Act asks three things of anyone who sells a subscription online: disclose all material terms clearly before taking billing information, get the customer's express informed consent before charging, and provide simple mechanisms to stop recurring charges (15 U.S.C. § 8403). It is a short statute. This fall it became the main federal rulebook for telehealth checkouts, because the FTC's click-to-cancel rule was vacated in July 2025 and no replacement has been proposed.

Zealthy, Southern District of Florida. In United States v. Cerebral, Inc. et al. (No. 1:24-cv-21376), the government settled with Cerebral and kept suing its founder Kyle Robertson and his later company, Zealthy. The court's order denying Zealthy's and Robertson's motion to dismiss Count I of the third amended complaint, a motion filed July 10, 2026, finds the complaint sufficiently pleads "a failure to disclose the specific pricing and full cost" of Zealthy's telehealth services and medications, and that it plausibly alleges the defendants knew of consumer complaints about cancellation obstacles and unauthorized charges (Justia, Document 302). VitalLaw reported on October 30 that the court held the Department of Justice had adequately pleaded its ROSCA and FTC Act claims, applying the heightened standard for claims that sound in fraud, and that the case moves to discovery (VitalLaw). These are allegations. Surviving a motion to dismiss means the claims can go forward, not that they are true.

Hims & Hers, Northern District of California. The FTC, Utah and California authorities sued in July over charging at intake, a hidden cancel path and health-data sharing. On October 22 Hims moved to dismiss all nine counts, arguing among other things that its privacy policy disclosed the sharing. Judge Vince Chhabria has set a hearing for January 7, 2027, and an MLex headline on October 30 said the case "appears headed for trial" (MLex). The motion was pending as of early November. Our September post on the complaint covers the three practices in detail.

Read together, the two cases tell you which facts a regulator builds on: what the patient was told the total cost would be, when the card was charged, and what happened when they tried to leave.


The audit, line by line

Run it on your live checkout with a test card, as a new patient would. Screenshot every step. Where a row says "evidence," that is the thing you should be able to produce for any order a regulator, a card network or a patient's lawyer asks about.

#ElementWhat the law asksWhat to checkEvidence to keep
1Disclosure placementROSCA: all material terms before billing information. Louisiana: renewal terms in visual proximity to the acceptance requestProgram fee, drug cost (or how it is billed), interval, renewal date, how to cancel, all visible above the card field without clicking outScreenshot of the checkout as served, by version and date
2Total costThe Zealthy order turns on "specific pricing and full cost"Can a patient see what month three costs, including dose changes and labs?Pricing page and checkout copy, versioned
3Express consentROSCA: express informed consent. California: separate consent to the auto-renewal. Louisiana: affirmative acceptanceAn unchecked box or a button that names the renewal ("Start my $129/month plan"), separate from terms of serviceTimestamp, IP, consent text version, linked to the order
4Charge timingROSCA consent must come before the chargeCard authorized at checkout, captured only when a provider approvesAuthorization and capture timestamps next to the approval timestamp
5Renewal noticeCalifornia: annual reminder; notice before a trial or promo longer than 31 days ends. Louisiana: at least 3 days before renewal of 1-year or longer terms, before trial conversion, and on material changesA notice before every charge, with amount, date and a cancel linkCopy of each notice sent, with send time
6Cancellation pathROSCA: simple mechanism. California: online if signed up online. NYC: as easy as enrollment, same channelsCancel from the account page, in one flow, with no call or chatCancel request timestamp, effective date
7Retention offersCalifornia allows them only beside a prominent cancel optionPause or dose change offered on the cancel screen; cancel still completes thereScreenshot of the cancel screen
8Confirmation emailsCalifornia: an acknowledgment with the terms and how to cancel. Louisiana: an acknowledgmentOrder email repeats price, interval, renewal date and how to cancel; cancel email states the effective date and last chargeSent copies, linked to the patient record

Two rows deserve extra attention because they are where telehealth checkouts differ from ordinary subscriptions.

Row 2. A GLP-1 or TRT patient's price changes with the dose, and labs or a drug bought through a manufacturer channel may be billed separately. A checkout that shows "$99/month" and leaves the medication cost to a later email has the shape of the allegation the Florida court let stand. Show the dose ladder or a link to it at the card step. Our 2027 GLP-1 pricing post has an example of a price table that holds up.

Row 4. Charging on intake is the Hims fact pattern. Authorize, then capture on clinical approval, and say so in one sentence above the button.


The state overlay

ROSCA is the floor. Most brands serve California, and two more jurisdictions changed this year.

JurisdictionIn forceWhat it adds
California (Bus. & Prof. Code § 17600 et seq.)Now; AB 2863 amendments since July 1, 2025Online cancellation for online sign-ups, separate express consent to the renewal, annual reminder, retention offers only next to a prominent cancel option
New York City ruleOctober 1, 2026Cancellation as easy as enrollment through the same channels; restitution for charges after the first cancel attempt; civil penalties of $525, $1,050 and $3,500 for first, second and later violations
Louisiana Act 830 (HB 750)January 1, 2027Clear renewal terms near the acceptance request, affirmative acceptance and an acknowledgment, 3-day notice for 1-year terms and trial conversions, notice of material changes, an easy cancellation method, consent records kept at least one year; up to $500 per violation after an Attorney General notice and 30-day cure period

Sources: Kelley Drye's summer 2026 roundup for NYC and Louisiana; § 17602 and our refund policy post for California. Louisiana's act has small-business exemptions (Kelley Drye notes provisions that conflict on this), so check with counsel before relying on one.

Our view: build once to the strictest version and serve everyone the same flow. A Louisiana-only notice schedule is more code and more risk than sending every patient a notice three days before every charge, which is what we would do anyway.


The record test

Pick one order from last month at random. Within an hour, can you produce:

  • the checkout screen the patient saw that day, with the price and renewal terms,
  • the consent record (time, text version, what they clicked),
  • the authorization, the provider approval and the capture, with times,
  • every renewal notice sent and every charge made,
  • the cancel request, if any, and the email that confirmed it?

If any item takes a support ticket to an outside vendor, that is your finding. Louisiana will require a year of consent records from January. In a dispute, the same file decides whether a chargeback sticks, and Visa's 1.5% dispute threshold has applied since April 1, 2026 (our VAMP post).

This is not legal advice; ask a consumer-protection lawyer to review your checkout against the states you serve.


What a billing platform can do, and what it cannot

A platform can make rows 4 through 8 the default. On Turbopills, the subscription starts when a provider approves, not when the intake is submitted; failed charges retry automatically; refunds are one click from the admin console; and cancellation and order status live in the patient portal. Renewal reminders and receipts are part of the billing engine.

What a platform cannot do is write your price. Rows 1 to 3 are copy and design decisions, and the Florida order is a reminder that the words on the checkout are what gets read in court. Ask any vendor, us included, to show you a full order history for one test patient, from consent to cancellation, in the demo. We are in private beta and will run that walkthrough on request.


FAQ

Is the FTC click-to-cancel rule in effect? No. The Eighth Circuit vacated it on July 8, 2025, and the FTC reopened rulemaking in March 2026 without a new rule so far. ROSCA still requires clear disclosure, express consent and a simple way to cancel, and state laws such as California's add more.

What is the Zealthy lawsuit about? The Justice Department, on behalf of the FTC, alleges that Zealthy and its CEO Kyle Robertson did not clearly disclose pricing and full costs and made cancellation hard, in violation of ROSCA and the FTC Act. VitalLaw reported on October 30 that the Florida federal court let the claims proceed to discovery. The allegations have not been proven.

When is the Hims FTC hearing? A hearing on Hims & Hers' October 22 motion to dismiss is set for January 7, 2027 before Judge Vince Chhabria in the Northern District of California.

What does Louisiana's click-to-cancel law require? From January 1, 2027: clear renewal terms near the acceptance request, affirmative consent with an acknowledgment, a renewal notice at least three days before renewal of terms of a year or longer and before trial conversions, notice of material changes, an easy cancellation method, and consent records kept for at least a year.

More from Operations